Swing-blade vs band sawmill (and where a chainsaw mill fits)

A swing-blade sawmill cuts with a circular blade that pivots, so it sets up over the log and saws boards without turning it. A band sawmill runs a thin, continuous blade through a log loaded onto its bed. A chainsaw mill guides your chainsaw. Which fits depends on your logs and what you want out of them.

A Lucas Mill swing-blade sawing head over a freshly cut log, with boards coming off the top

By Bailey's sawmill team · Updated · 5 min read

How each mill cuts

Swing-blade sawmill. One circular blade cuts the vertical face, pivots 90 degrees and cuts the horizontal face, freeing a board. The mill’s frame and rails go up around the log, and the carriage runs along them, so the log stays where it lies. Boards wider than one pass come from a double cut, one pass from each side. Lucas Mill makes the swing-blade mills Bailey’s carries.

Band sawmill. A thin band blade runs around two wheels, and the head travels along a track while the log sits on the bed. The sawyer turns the log between cuts to square it and take boards. Band mills are made in portable and stationary forms; industrial band headrigs, such as the ones on our industrial sawmills page, are the stationary end of the family.

Chainsaw mill. A frame clamps to a chainsaw’s bar and rides on a guide rail for the first cut, then on the flat face of the log. The saw does the cutting with ripping chain. Granberg’s Alaskan mills are the chainsaw mills Bailey’s sells.

Swing-blade vs band sawmill: the honest trade-offs

Swing-blade vs band sawmill
Swing-blade sawmillBand sawmill
BladeOne circular blade with replaceable teethA thin band blade, tensioned and tracked on two wheels
KerfWider than a bandThinner, so less wood goes to sawdust
Where it sets upOver the log, where it liesThe log is loaded onto the mill’s bed
Turning the logNot needed for boards; the blade swingsNeeded to square the log and take boards
Widest board in one passSet by the blade’s reach; wider boards by double cutSet by the throat between the band wheels
Wide slabsWith a slabbing attachment or a dedicated slabberUp to the mill’s throat width
Blade upkeepSharpen or replace teeth on the bladeSharpen and set bands; keep tension and tracking right

Kerf. The band’s thinner kerf is its main advantage: more of each log becomes lumber, which matters most with valuable hardwoods. Lucas Mill publishes a 5 mm kerf for the 6-16 and 5.7 mm for the 8-30.

Logs that are hard to move. The swing-blade’s main advantage is that the log doesn’t have to come to the mill. Big logs, logs on a slope or in the bush, and logs you can’t lift onto a bed can be sawn where they lie. A band mill needs the log on its bed, which for large logs means a loader or a tractor.

Upkeep. A band blade has to be tensioned and tracked, and bands are sharpened and set. A swing-blade’s circular blade is sharpened tooth by tooth. Neither is hard once you’ve learned it; they’re different jobs.

Dimensional lumber and beams. A swing-blade cuts square-edged boards straight off the log, so dimensional lumber, posts and beams come off with no separate edging. On a band mill, you edge boards by turning them on the bed or with an edger.

Where a chainsaw mill fits

A chainsaw mill is the third option, and the lowest cost: a frame for a saw you may already own. It cuts the widest slabs for the money, because the width is set by the bar, and it goes anywhere you can carry a saw. Granberg publishes a cut up to 32 in wide for the 36 in Alaskan MKIV, and wider mills take longer bars.

The trade-offs: it’s slower than a swing-blade or a band mill, the kerf is the widest of the three, and it’s hard work on the saw and the operator. For a few logs a year, or slabs from a tree too big to move, it’s often the right tool. Read how to use an Alaskan chainsaw mill.

Circular sawmills: swing-blade and fixed-blade

“Circular sawmill” covers two kinds. A traditional circular sawmill uses one large fixed blade, with the log carried past it on a carriage; that is the classic stationary mill. A swing-blade is a portable circular sawmill whose blade pivots so it can make both cuts. When people ask for a portable circular sawmill today, they usually mean a swing-blade. See our portable sawmills.

How to choose

  • Your logs are big, far from a road, or hard to load: a swing-blade sawmill, set up where the log lies.
  • You saw valuable hardwood where every board counts, and logs can come to the mill: a band sawmill’s thinner kerf is worth weighing.
  • You want beams, posts and dimensional lumber with square edges straight off the log: a swing-blade.
  • You want wide slabs on a small budget, from a few logs: a chainsaw mill.
  • Wide slabs as a regular product: a swing-blade with a slabbing attachment, or a dedicated slabber. See slabbing mills.
  • Production, measured by the shift: an industrial line with a headrig. See industrial sawmills.

For prices by class, see how much a sawmill costs.

Questions sawyers ask

Anything else, call a specialist at 1-888-465-8227.

Is a swing-blade sawmill better than a band sawmill?

Neither is better for every job. A swing-blade sawmill sets up over the log and cuts square-edged boards without turning it, which suits big or hard-to-move logs. A band sawmill cuts a thinner kerf, which gets more lumber from each log, but the log has to be loaded onto the mill.

What is the difference between a chainsaw mill and a bandsaw mill?

A chainsaw mill is a frame that guides your chainsaw through the log; it costs far less and goes anywhere, but it is slower and cuts a wider kerf. A bandsaw mill is a dedicated machine with a thin band blade, faster and more efficient, but the log has to be loaded onto it.

Is a swing-blade sawmill a circular sawmill?

Yes. A swing-blade sawmill is a portable circular sawmill: its single circular blade pivots 90 degrees to make both the vertical and horizontal cuts. A traditional circular sawmill uses a large fixed blade with the log carried past it.

Does a swing-blade sawmill need the log turned?

Not to cut boards. The blade swings from vertical to horizontal, so each board comes off while the log stays where it lies. Lucas Mill swing-blade mills set up on rails over the log.

Does Bailey’s sell band sawmills?

Bailey’s sells Lucas Mill swing-blade sawmills, Granberg chainsaw mills and, on the industrial side, Wood-Mizer and Wravor sawmill systems. Tell a specialist what you cut and we’ll tell you which fits.

Talk to a sawmill specialist

Tell us about your operation and the equipment you're interested in. A Bailey's sawmill specialist will get back to you.

Fields marked optional can be skipped. Everything else helps the specialist quote the right setup.

More about your job (optional)

Interested in financing?
Best way to reach you

We use your details to answer this request. See Bailey's privacy policy and terms.

Industrial Sales Group

1-888-465-8227

Lucas Mill portable and slabbing mills, Granberg chainsaw mills, and industrial sawmill systems.

Equipment Financing

Financing is available on sawmill equipment. See the options or apply online.

Prefer email? sales@baileysonline.com